What is the difference between APR and APY of liquidity pools? How to calculate real returns?

Understanding APR in Liquidity Pools

In the world of decentralized finance (DeFi), liquidity pools are essential for enabling automated trading on platforms like Uniswap, SushiSwap, and PancakeSwap. When users provide liquidity to these pools, they earn rewards, often expressed as APR (Annual Percentage Rate). APR is a simple interest calculation that represents the estimated annual return without compounding.

For example, if a liquidity pool offers an APR of 100%, it means that if you deposit $100 today, you would expect to earn $100 in rewards over the course of one year. However, this assumes no changes in the value of the assets or the reward rate. It's important to note that APR does not account for compounded earnings, which can significantly affect returns over time.

Understanding APY in Liquidity Pools

Unlike APR, APY (Annual Percentage Yield) includes the effect of compounding interest. Compounding occurs when your earned rewards are reinvested into the liquidity pool, generating additional returns. This makes APY a more accurate reflection of potential earnings over time, especially in environments where rewards are distributed frequently and automatically added to the user’s position.

For instance, if a pool has an APY of 100%, it means that with daily compounding, your initial investment could potentially double within a year due to the reinvestment of rewards. The key difference between APR and APY lies in the compounding frequency — the more frequent the compounding, the higher the APY will be compared to APR.

Why APR and APY Values Differ in DeFi Platforms

On many DeFi dashboards, you'll see both APR and APY values displayed for liquidity pools. These numbers can vary widely because of how they're calculated and the assumptions made by each platform. APR is usually static, showing a linear growth model, while APY assumes reinvestment of rewards, leading to exponential growth.

Another factor contributing to the discrepancy is volatility in token prices. If the assets in the liquidity pool experience significant price fluctuations, the actual returns may diverge from both APR and APY estimates. Additionally, some platforms calculate APR based on short-term reward emissions, which might not be sustainable over the long term, causing APY figures to appear inflated.

How to Calculate Real Returns from Liquidity Pools

To determine your real returns, you must go beyond APR and APY and consider several variables:

• Impermanent loss: This occurs when the ratio of assets in the pool changes due to market price movements.
• Token price volatility: Earnings denominated in volatile tokens can lose or gain value quickly.
• Compounding frequency: If you manually compound or use auto-compound vaults, this affects total yield.
• Fees and taxes: Gas fees, withdrawal fees, and tax implications also impact net returns.

To calculate real returns, start by tracking your initial investment value, then monitor the total value of your liquidity provider (LP) tokens over time. Subtract any losses from impermanent loss and adjust for token price changes. Then compare this final amount to your initial deposit to get your actual ROI (Return on Investment).

Manual Calculation of APR and APY

If you want to calculate APR and APY yourself rather than rely on platform data, here's how:

Calculating APR:

APR = (Daily Rewards  365 / Total Liquidity Provided)  100

For example, if you earn $1 per day in rewards and have provided $1000 worth of liquidity:

APR = (1  365 / 1000)  100 = 36.5%

Calculating APY:

APY = (1 + r/n)^n - 1

Where:

• r is the periodic rate (daily reward divided by principal)
• n is the number of compounding periods per year

If the daily rate is 0.1% and compounding happens daily (n=365):

APY = (1 + 0.001)^365 - 1 ≈ 44.02%

This shows how compounding increases the effective yield beyond APR.

Using Tools and Calculators for Accurate Return Estimation

Many DeFi users rely on tools like APY calculators, portfolio trackers, or auto-compounding yield optimizers to better estimate their returns. Platforms such as APY.Vision or Zapper.fi allow users to input their positions and simulate future earnings based on current APR/APY rates and compounding intervals.

Some advanced users even create custom spreadsheets to track their investments across multiple pools. These sheets typically include columns for:

• Date of deposit
• Initial asset amounts
• Current asset amounts
• Reward tokens received
• Price data at different timestamps
• Net profit/loss calculations

By integrating APIs or manually updating price data, users can generate accurate performance reports over time.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q: Can APR ever be higher than APY?A: No, APR cannot be higher than APY when compounding is involved. APY always reflects compounded growth, so it will either equal APR (if there's no compounding) or be higher.

Q: Why do some platforms only show APR instead of APY?A: Some platforms prefer displaying APR because it provides a simpler, non-compounded view of returns. It avoids misleading users who may not understand compounding effects or assume those returns are guaranteed.

Q: How does impermanent loss affect APR and APY calculations?A: Impermanent loss reduces the actual returns compared to APR and APY figures shown on platforms. Since APR and APY don't account for asset price divergence, users must subtract any impermanent loss from their total earnings to get accurate results.

Q: Are APR and APY values reliable indicators of profitability?A: While useful for estimation, APR and APY should not be taken as guarantees. They can fluctuate due to changes in reward emissions, token prices, and market conditions. Always conduct further analysis before investing.