Rumors of Ripple Acquiring Circle Have Been Spreading, But the Valuation Doesn't Make Sense

Rumors of Ripple potentially acquiring Circle have spread on social media, driven by reports of their strategic alignment in the stablecoin market.

Rumors have been swirling on social media about the possibility of Ripple acquiring Circle, with reports suggesting the two companies could be aligning their strategies in the stablecoin market.

However, according to crypto commentator Dom in a recent post on X, there is little chance that Ripple would offer anything close to $20 billion to acquire Circle. A more realistic valuation for Circle, according to Dom, would be around $5 billion, which better reflects the company’s financial performance.

“fyi @circle IPO valuation is ~$5 billion (which is the valuation Ripple is looking at when it made its acquisition offer).

ps i see lots of people saying $5 billion is a low offer since circle holds $60 billion in USDC and they have huge user base. but USDC liquidity is not transferrable to another entity. it will be liquidated if anything. also, circle’s revenue model is mainly yield on these reserves, not user fees or transaction fees like other crypto companies. so we should value circle based on its income potential, not the collateral.”

Understanding Circle’s True Valuation

Circle, the issuer of the popular USD Coin (USDC) stablecoin, is a well-known player in the digital payments industry. Currently, Circle manages the issuance of approximately $60 billion worth of USDC, all of which is backed by collateralized reserves in highly liquid assets such as U.S. Treasuries and cash equivalents.

This large reserve figure often leads some to believe that the company itself is valued at $60 billion, but Dom clarifies that this isn’t the case. The assets are specifically allocated to back the stablecoins in circulation, not to build up Circle’s balance sheet. Instead, Circle generates revenue through the yield realized on these reserves.

This yield—accumulated from interest on short-term government securities and other low-risk instruments—contributes to Circle’s earnings, which in turn determine its enterprise valuation.

Ripple’s Acquisition Logic Doesn’t Support a $20 Billion Bid

Considering this business model, Dom argues that Circle’s $5 billion IPO valuation is a more accurate assessment of its income potential. From a corporate finance standpoint, it’s unlikely that Ripple would offer a premium of 4x over that figure, especially since the collateral backing USDC isn’t transferrable or revenue-generating.

With its own ambitions in the stablecoin space and broader payments ecosystem, Ripple has little incentive to overpay for Circle. The company recently announced its entry into the stablecoin market with RLUSD, a new XRP Ledger-native stablecoin backed 1:1 by U.S. dollar reserves.

As Ripple is now launching its own digital dollar equivalent, a $20 billion acquisition bid for a competitor seems even less plausible. The decision to acquire a company like Circle would depend on various factors, including current revenue, future cash flows, regulatory risks, and market competitive landscape.

Given the increasing regulatory scrutiny on stablecoins and Circle’s revenue model, which is largely dependent on interest rates, paying a high premium would carry significant risks.

Market Misunderstandings and Misinformation

Dom’s post also touches upon a broader misunderstanding within the crypto community: conflating collateral managed by a company with its equity value. This oversight can inflate company valuations, especially in the stablecoin sector, where a large portion of assets are held in custody.

To be clear, the $60 billion in assets isn’t available for Circle to use for growth or acquisitions. These funds are specifically allocated to redeem USDC if needed.

Instead, Circle’s enterprise value should be assessed through more standard metrics, such as revenue potential from interest earnings, future growth prospects, expansion of their user base, and strategic positioning in the broader market. All of these fundamentals contribute to the $5 billion valuation, not the speculative $20 billion figure.

Rational Valuations in an Evolving Ecosystem

As the competition in the stablecoin market intensifies with new entrants like PayPal and financial institutions joining the space, strategic acquisitions will likely play a role in shaping the future of digital finance. However, companies like Ripple, which take a calculated, enterprise-focused approach, are unlikely to be easily enticed into making such moves.

Ripple is known for its focus on utility, scalability, and sustainable revenue models, which suggests they wouldn’t be easily swayed by hype. Dom’s breakdown of Circle’s valuation highlights why any serious acquisition offer would be grounded in financial reality.