Scroll 的币安上市引发了关于去中心化担忧的争论

此举于 10 月 11 日宣布，引发了加密社区的激烈争论。人们质疑 Scroll 是否坚持其去中心化价值观，还是过于倾向于中心化。

Scroll’s recent move to get listed on Binance has sparked a heated debate within the crypto community, particularly regarding the trade-offs between centralization and decentralization.

Scroll 最近在币安上市的举动引发了加密货币社区的激烈争论，特别是关于中心化和去中心化之间的权衡。

While some welcome the listing, arguing that it could help Scroll expand rapidly, especially in new markets, and that Binance's services, such as providing easy ways to move funds in and out of the Scroll network, could ultimately enhance user-friendliness, others contend that partnering with a centralized exchange, like Binance, runs counter to the core ethos of decentralization that many in the crypto world champion.

虽然一些人对此次上市表示欢迎，但也有人认为，它可以帮助 Scroll 快速扩张，尤其是在新市场，而币安的服务（例如提供将资金移入和移出 Scroll 网络的简单方法）最终可以提高用户友好性与币安这样的中心化交易所合作，与许多加密货币世界冠军的去中心化核心精神背道而驰。

One X (formerly Twitter) user, Zeng Jiajun, highlighted this tension in his commentary on Scroll's choice to get listed on Binance.

One X（前 Twitter）用户 Zeng Jiajun 在他对 Scroll 选择在币安上市的评论中强调了这种紧张关系。

In his view, the decision feels like Scroll is “kneeling” to a centralized exchange, and while he acknowledges that it was likely a difficult choice, he wonders about the implications for Scroll's future. The use of the term “kneeling” is particularly evocative, suggesting that Scroll may be sacrificing some of its independence for the sake of growth.

在他看来，这一决定感觉像是 Scroll 向中心化交易所“跪下”，虽然他承认这可能是一个艰难的选择，但他想知道这对 Scroll 的未来有何影响。 “跪”这个词的使用特别能引起人们的共鸣，这表明 Scroll 可能为了增长而牺牲了一些独立性。

It’s a tough decision to make. I strongly doubt that it’s a good decision long term.

这是一个艰难的决定。我强烈怀疑从长远来看这是否是一个好的决定。

Imagine @VitalikButerin paying 5.5% to @okx when @star_okx refused to list $ETH.

想象一下，当 @star_okx 拒绝列出 $ETH 时，@VitalikButerin 向 @okx 支付 5.5%。

I like everyone in the scroll team, but kneeling to CEX is really disappointing. https://t.co/SsLYt5eFZU

卷轴团队的每一个人我都喜欢，但是跪到CEX实在是让人失望。 https://t.co/SsLYt5eFZU

However, Scroll's co-founder, Ye Zhang, has offered a defense of the decision, emphasizing that partnering with Binance is not merely about getting listed but about exploring avenues for growth, particularly in emerging markets.

然而，Scroll 的联合创始人张晔对这一决定进行了辩护，强调与币安的合作不仅仅是为了上市，而是为了探索增长途径，特别是在新兴市场。

According to Zhang, Binance's services, including the opening of on-ramp and off-ramp channels, will ultimately help more people easily access the Scroll network. In his words, “It's way more than just a listing. It’s a partnership for growth and broader support.”

张表示，币安的服务，包括开放入口和出口通道，最终将帮助更多人轻松接入Scroll网络。用他的话说，“这不仅仅是一个列表。这是一种促进增长和更广泛支持的伙伴关系。”

For us, Binance is more than just a listing, it’s the best channel to reach global distribution, it will open the on-ramp and off-ramp channels and help us grow to the next stage, especially in emerging markets.

对我们来说，币安不仅仅是一个上市，它是到达全球分销的最佳渠道，它将打开入口和出口通道，帮助我们成长到下一阶段，特别是在新兴市场。

ETH deposits and withdrawals on Scroll are now live on Binance,…

Scroll 上的 ETH 存款和取款现已在 Binance 上上线，……

Despite Zhang's perspective, not everyone shares his optimism, and a common concern among many in the crypto space is the potential erosion of Scroll's decentralization as a result of the deal with Binance.

尽管张的观点如此，但并不是每个人都像他一样乐观，加密货币领域许多人的共同担忧是，与币安的交易可能会削弱 Scroll 的去中心化能力。

The worry is that over-reliance on a large, centralized exchange could lead to a concentration of power in the hands of a few, ultimately steering Scroll away from the core values of crypto. These critics express apprehension that Scroll may be walking a precarious tightrope between rapid growth and staying true to its decentralized ethos.

令人担忧的是，过度依赖大型中心化交易所可能会导致权力集中在少数人手中，最终导致 Scroll 远离加密货币的核心价值。这些批评者担心 Scroll 可能在快速增长和保持去中心化精神之间走钢丝。