Is it dangerous that the price hits a new high but the MACD red column fails to expand?

A new price high without MACD histogram expansion signals weakening momentum and potential bearish divergence, warning traders of possible trend reversal or pullback.

Jun 25, 2025 at 01:42 am

Understanding the MACD Indicator and Its Components

The Moving Average Convergence Divergence (MACD) is a popular technical analysis tool used in cryptocurrency trading to identify potential trend reversals or continuations. It consists of three main components: the MACD line, the signal line, and the MACD histogram (often referred to as the red column). The MACD line is calculated by subtracting the 26-period Exponential Moving Average (EMA) from the 12-period EMA. The signal line is typically a 9-period EMA of the MACD line, while the histogram represents the difference between these two lines.

When the price reaches a new high but the MACD red column fails to expand, it may signal a divergence between momentum and price action. This phenomenon is often interpreted as a warning sign for traders. In this context, understanding how each component interacts becomes crucial for assessing market conditions accurately.

---

What Does a New Price High Mean?

A new price high in the crypto market generally indicates strong bullish sentiment. Traders interpret this as a sign that buyers are in control and that demand continues to outweigh supply. However, not all new highs are created equal. If the MACD histogram does not confirm this move with an expanding red bar, it suggests that the upward momentum might be weakening despite rising prices.

In traditional technical analysis, such a situation is known as a bearish divergence. This occurs when the price makes higher highs, but the oscillator—in this case, the MACD histogram—makes lower highs. It implies that although the price is climbing, the underlying strength of the uptrend is diminishing. This can lead to sudden pullbacks or even trend reversals.

---

Why the MACD Red Column Fails to Expand

There are several reasons why the MACD red column may fail to expand during a new price high:

• Waning Buying Pressure: Even though the price is moving up, fewer buyers are stepping in to push the rally further.
• Profit-Taking by Large Holders: Whales or institutional investors may be selling off positions at resistance levels, slowing momentum.
• Market Exhaustion: A prolonged rally without corrections can lead to fatigue among retail traders, resulting in weaker volume and momentum indicators.
• Hidden Distribution: Smart money may be distributing their holdings quietly, leading to a lack of real momentum behind the price rise.

Each of these scenarios contributes to a situation where the MACD histogram shrinks instead of growing, signaling that the current bullish movement may not be sustainable.

---

How to Identify This Scenario on Charts

To spot this condition on a chart, follow these steps:

• Look for a clear new high in price across major timeframes (e.g., 4-hour, daily).
• Observe the corresponding MACD histogram values at those highs.
• Compare the height of the red bars during previous highs versus the current one.
• Ensure that the MACD line remains above the signal line, confirming the uptrend is still technically intact, even if momentum is fading.

This visual comparison helps traders identify potential bearish divergences early. Tools like TradingView allow users to draw trendlines on the histogram itself, making it easier to compare peaks and valleys in momentum relative to price action.

---

Implications for Cryptocurrency Traders

For active traders, especially those involved in swing or day trading within the crypto space, recognizing this divergence can be vital. When the price hits a new high but the MACD red column doesn't expand, it's often seen as a warning sign rather than a sell signal. Here’s what different types of traders might consider:

• Day Traders: May look to reduce long exposure or initiate short positions once confirmation patterns appear, such as a bearish candlestick reversal near resistance.
• Swing Traders: Might tighten stop-losses or take partial profits off the table to protect gains.
• Long-Term Investors: Could view this as a consolidation phase and wait for clearer signals before adjusting positions.

It’s also important to cross-reference other indicators like Relative Strength Index (RSI) or volume profiles to gain a more comprehensive picture before making any decisions.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can a shrinking MACD red column ever be bullish?

A: Yes, depending on the context. If the price is in a downtrend and begins to rise while the MACD histogram contracts negative bars (green columns), it could indicate strengthening bullish momentum.

Q: Should I immediately sell if I see this divergence?

A: No. A divergence is a warning, not a definitive signal. Confirmatory price action or additional indicators should be used before executing trades.

Q: Is this pattern reliable in volatile crypto markets?

A: While no indicator is foolproof, the MACD histogram divergence has historically provided useful insights in both trending and ranging crypto markets. However, false signals can occur due to high volatility.

Q: How do I differentiate between a normal pullback and a bearish divergence?

A: A normal pullback usually sees the MACD histogram retrace proportionally with price movement. In contrast, a bearish divergence shows the histogram failing to match the price’s new high, indicating weakening momentum.