比特币SV索赔受法院裁决的限制

英国上诉法院已部分驳回了针对Binance和其他交易所的133亿美元诉讼。该案件涉及反竞争行为的指控

The UK Court of Appeal has partially dismissed a $13.3 billion lawsuit against Binance and other exchanges over the 2019 delisting of Bitcoin SV (BSV).

英国上诉法院已部分驳回了针对Binance的133亿美元诉讼，并在2019年将比特币SV（BSV）推荐方面进行了交流。

The case arose when BSV holders sued Binance, Kraken, ShapeShift, and Bittylicious for allegedly anti-competitive conduct that drove down the token’s price.

当BSV持有人起诉Binance，Kraken，ShapeShift和Bittylicious涉嫌反竞争性行为时，该案发生了。

The plaintiffs argued that Binance’s decision to delist BSV limited the coin’s chance to grow like Bitcoin (BTC) or Bitcoin Cash (BCH), claiming $13.3 billion in damages—352 times the value of BSV held at the time.

原告辩称，Binance决定BSV的决定限制了硬币像比特币（BTC）或比特币现金（BCH）一样成长的机会，要求赔偿133亿美元，这是当时持有的BSV价值的352倍。

However, the court found this claim unsustainable, noting that BSV had viable substitutes and lacked uniqueness in the market. It ruled that holders cannot base losses on the hypothetical growth of unrelated tokens.

但是，法院认为这一说法不可持续，并指出BSV具有可行的替代品，并且在市场上缺乏独特性。它裁定，持有人不能基于无关代币的假设增长的损失。

Moreover, the court applied the market mitigation rule to dismiss claims based on future price speculation after the delisting became public. It emphasized that crypto tokens are volatile and similar to shares and other tradable financial assets.

此外，法院将市场缓解规则应用于脱颖而出的公开后基于未来价格投机的索赔。它强调，加密代币是波动的，类似于股票和其他可交易金融资产。

The ruling confirms that damages must reflect actual loss, not missed opportunities from possible market movement, as the court prioritized a realistic assessment of financial harm.

该裁决证实，损害赔偿必须反映出实际损失，而不是可能因市场转移而错过的机会，因为法院优先考虑对财务危害的现实评估。

The court’s decision has limited Binance’s legal risk and significantly reduced the potential payout.

法院的裁决限制了Binance的法律风险，并大大降低了潜在的支出。

Binance, Kraken, ShapeShift, and Bittylicious were accused of delisting BSV to damage its value and prevent it from reaching the same levels as BTC or BCH.

Binance，Kraken，ShapeShift和Bittylicious被指控将BSV推迟以损害其价值，并防止其达到与BTC或BCH相同的水平。

The ruling has narrowed the case’s scope, with only limited access and sale timing claims remaining viable.

该裁决范围缩小了案件的范围，只有有限的访问和销售时间索赔仍然可行。

Those who could not access or sell BSV immediately after the delisting may still have a case, but the court ruled that losses must be concrete and measurable.

那些在降价后无法立即访问或出售BSV的人仍可能有案件，但法院裁定损失必须具体且可衡量。

After the delisting, some users had difficulty accessing their BSV on Binance, while others sold quickly and recorded immediate, quantifiable losses. These claims could proceed.

在脱颖而出之后，一些用户很难访问其BSV，而另一些用户则很快出售并记录了立即可量化的损失。这些主张可以进行。

However, the court struck down the main claim, which sought to hold Binance liable for the difference between BSV’s price at the time of delisting and the potential highs it could have reached if listed.

但是，法院驳回了主要主张，该主张试图对BSV价格在推翻时的价格和如果列出时可能达到的潜在高点之间的差额承担责任。

Binance argued that the claimants retained ownership of BSV and could act freely after the delisting event. The court agreed, stating that knowledge of the delisting removed any responsibility from Binance.

Binance辩称，索赔人保留了BSV的所有权，并且可以在提取事件后自由行动。法院同意，并指出，对非凡的知识取消了Binance的任何责任。

This finding significantly undermined the larger claim for damages, which aimed to compensate users for the potential gains they missed out on due to Binance’s actions.

这一发现极大地破坏了对损害赔偿的较大索赔，该赔偿旨在补偿用户由于唯一的行动而错过的潜在收益。

Despite dismissing the main claim, the British judges allowed smaller claims against Binance to continue.

尽管驳回了主要主张，但英国法官允许对Binance的较小主张继续进行。

These include cases where users could not access their BSV following the delisting action, or sold quickly and recorded immediate, quantifiable losses.

这些案例包括用户无法在采取挑剔行动之后无法访问其BSV，或迅速出售并记录立即可量化的损失。

These claims could proceed under a revised legal framework, with a much lower total exposure.

这些索赔可以根据修订后的法律框架进行，总敞口较低。

The court stressed that only the pre-delisting value and proven additional losses could be claimed. Binance remains involved but with reduced liability and no obligation to cover projected gains.

法院强调，只有预先列出的价值和证明的额外损失才能被要求。 Binance仍然参与其中，但责任降低，没有承保预计收益的义务。

Meanwhile, Binance continues to dominate crypto trading, with Dune Analytics reporting over $5 billion in daily wallet volume. The UK is also increasing regulatory oversight, mandating detailed transaction reporting from 2026.

同时，Binance继续主导加密交易，Dune Analytics报告的每日钱包数量超过50亿美元。英国还在增加监管监督，从2026年开始强制详细的交易报告。

Binance and other platforms must comply with growing legal and regulatory scrutiny across the crypto industry.

Binance和其他平台必须遵守加密行业的法律和监管审查。