Is the MACD red column shortening when the volume and price rise together? Is it a weakening of momentum or a short break?

A shortening red MACD column with rising price and volume suggests weakening bearish momentum, but confirmation via RSI, OBV, and key support levels is essential to avoid false signals.

Jul 30, 2025 at 02:42 pm

Understanding the MACD Indicator and Its Components

The MACD (Moving Average Convergence Divergence) is a widely used technical analysis tool in the cryptocurrency trading community. It consists of three primary elements: the MACD line, the signal line, and the histogram (often referred to as the "column"). The histogram visually represents the difference between the MACD line and the signal line. When the histogram appears in red, it indicates that the MACD line is below the signal line, suggesting bearish momentum. A shortening red column means the gap between these two lines is narrowing, even though the overall trend remains bearish.

Traders often misinterpret the shortening of the red column as a reversal signal. However, this narrowing can occur under various market conditions. In a strong downtrend, the red column may shorten temporarily due to a pullback or consolidation, not necessarily signaling a trend reversal. The key lies in evaluating this signal in conjunction with other indicators, especially price action and volume.

Price and Volume Rising Together: What It Signifies

When both price and volume are rising simultaneously in a cryptocurrency market, it typically reflects strong buying pressure. This combination is often seen as a bullish confirmation, especially if it occurs after a downtrend or during a breakout. A rising price with increasing volume suggests that market participants are actively entering long positions, which can drive further upward momentum.

In such a scenario, if the MACD red column is shortening, it aligns with the idea that bearish momentum is losing strength. The narrowing histogram indicates that the downward pressure is weakening, even if the MACD line hasn’t yet crossed above the signal line. This dynamic suggests a potential shift in momentum, but it does not confirm a reversal by itself. The convergence of rising price, rising volume, and a shortening red MACD column often points to a reduction in selling pressure and the possible emergence of bullish control.

Is the Momentum Weakening or Is It a Short Break?

Determining whether the shortening red column reflects weakening momentum or just a short break requires deeper analysis of the market structure. If the price is making higher lows and the volume on up-moves exceeds that on down-moves, the shortening red column likely indicates momentum weakening in the bearish direction. This could precede a bullish crossover if the MACD line crosses above the signal line.

However, if the price rise occurs within a narrow range and volume spikes are inconsistent, the shortening may represent only a short break in selling pressure. In this case, bears may regroup and resume the downtrend. To distinguish between the two, traders should examine:

• Whether the recent price candles show strong bullish closes
• If trading volume is consistently increasing on upward moves
• The presence of support levels or key moving averages nearby
• Whether the RSI (Relative Strength Index) is exiting oversold territory

A short break typically lacks sustained volume and fails to break key resistance, whereas weakening momentum often leads to structural changes in price behavior.

How to Confirm the Signal Using Additional Tools

To validate whether the shortening red MACD column amid rising price and volume is meaningful, traders should integrate supplementary technical tools. One effective method is to overlay the Volume Weighted Average Price (VWAP) to assess whether price is trading above or below fair value. A price above VWAP with rising volume strengthens the bullish case.

Another useful tool is the On-Balance Volume (OBV) indicator. If OBV is trending upward while the MACD red column shortens, it confirms that volume is supporting the price rise. Additionally, checking for divergence between price and MACD can offer insight. For example, if price makes a lower low but the MACD red column is shorter than before, this bullish divergence suggests weakening downside momentum.

Traders can also apply moving averages such as the 50-period and 200-period EMA. A price crossing above these averages with strong volume adds confirmation. Without such confluence, the shortening red column may be a false signal.

Step-by-Step Guide to Analyzing This Scenario on a Crypto Chart

• Open your preferred cryptocurrency trading platform (e.g., TradingView, Binance, or Bybit)
• Select the asset and timeframe (e.g., BTC/USDT on 4-hour chart)
• Apply the MACD indicator from the studies menu
• Enable volume at the bottom of the chart
• Identify a period where price is rising and volume bars are increasing
• Observe the MACD histogram — locate where the red columns begin to shorten
• Check if the MACD line is approaching the signal line from below
• Look for candlestick patterns such as bullish engulfing or hammer formations
• Add the RSI indicator and confirm it is moving above 50 or exiting oversold
• Plot horizontal support/resistance levels to see if price is breaking out
• Monitor order book depth on exchanges to confirm buying pressure

This structured approach ensures that the shortening red column is not interpreted in isolation. Each layer of confirmation reduces the risk of misreading temporary noise as a meaningful shift.

Common Misinterpretations and How to Avoid Them

Many traders assume that a shortening red MACD column automatically means a buy signal. This is a dangerous assumption, especially in volatile crypto markets. For instance, during a bear trap, price may briefly rise with volume as whales trigger stop-losses, causing the MACD column to shorten. However, the rally quickly reverses, trapping optimistic traders.

Another pitfall is ignoring the timeframe. A shortening red column on a 15-minute chart may just be noise, while the same pattern on a daily chart carries more weight. Always align your analysis with your trading strategy’s timeframe.

Also, low-liquidity altcoins can exhibit misleading volume spikes due to wash trading or pump-and-dump schemes. Verifying volume authenticity through on-chain data or exchange transparency metrics can prevent false signals.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

Can the MACD red column shorten during a downtrend?

Yes, the red column can shorten even within a downtrend. This usually happens during pullbacks or consolidation phases where selling pressure temporarily eases. It does not imply a reversal unless accompanied by rising price, strong volume, and a bullish MACD crossover.

Does a shortening red column always lead to a bullish crossover?

No, a shortening red column only indicates that bearish momentum is slowing. A bullish crossover occurs only when the MACD line crosses above the signal line. Many times, the column shortens, then begins expanding again without a crossover.

How does volume divergence affect this setup?

If volume is decreasing while price rises, it suggests weak participation, making the shortening red column less reliable. Conversely, increasing volume on up-moves strengthens the likelihood that the momentum shift is genuine.

Should I rely solely on MACD for trading decisions in crypto?

Relying solely on MACD is risky due to cryptocurrency’s volatility and lagging nature of the indicator. Always combine it with price action, volume analysis, and at least one additional momentum or volume-based indicator for better accuracy.