Scroll 上線幣安引發加密社群中心化爭論

以太坊二層計畫Scroll近日在中心化加密貨幣交易所幣安上線，引發了加密社群關於中心化的爭論。

Ethereum layer-2 project Scroll has been listed on major centralized cryptocurrency exchange Binance, sparking heated discussion in the crypto community about the trade-offs between centralization and growth.

以太坊二層計畫Scroll已登陸各大中心化加密貨幣交易所幣安，引發加密社群關於中心化與成長之間權衡的熱議。

The listing, which was announced on Oct. 11, has garnered mixed reactions due to Binance's status as a CEX. While the partnership is expected to boost Scroll's growth, some are concerned about the project's compromise on decentralization principles.

由於幣安的 CEX 地位，該交易所於 10 月 11 日宣布上市，引起了不同的反應。雖然此次合作預計將促進 Scroll 的成長，但有些人擔心該計畫在去中心化原則上的妥協。

X user Zeng "Jiajun" user Zeng highlighted Scroll's decision to list on Binance as "kneeling" to a CEX, calling it a "tough decision to make" but questioning its long-term implications.

X 用戶 Zeng “Jiajun”用戶 Zeng 強調 Scroll 在幣安上市的決定是對 CEX 的“跪下”，稱這是一個“艱難的決定”，但對其長期影響表示質疑。

Cointelegraph reached out to Scroll for comment but had not received a response by the time of publication.

Cointelegraph聯繫Scroll徵求意見，但截至發稿時尚未收到回覆。

However, Scroll co-founder Ye Zhang provided some insights into the partnership in an X post. According to Zhang, the partnership is part of a broader strategy to expand the project's ecosystem, especially in emerging markets.

不過，Scroll 聯合創辦人張曄在 X 貼文中提供了一些關於此次合作的見解。張表示，此次合作是擴大該專案生態系統（尤其是新興市場）的更廣泛策略的一部分。

"We chose Binance as the first exchange to partner with because of their massive user base and strong on-ramp and off-ramp capabilities," said Zhang.

「我們選擇幣安作為第一個合作夥伴，因為他們擁有龐大的用戶群和強大的進出能力，」張說。

The Scroll co-founder highlighted that Binance will facilitate user funds' movement in and out of the Scroll network through on-ramp and off-ramp services on Binance.

Scroll 聯合創辦人強調，幣安將透過幣安上的入口和出口服務促進用戶資金進出 Scroll 網路。

"This partnership will make it easier for users to participate in the Scroll ecosystem and benefit from the high throughput and low fees offered by our layer-2 solution," added Zhang.

張補充道：“這種合作關係將使用戶更容易參與 Scroll 生態系統，並從我們的第 2 層解決方案提供的高吞吐量和低費用中受益。”

However, not everyone in the crypto community shared Zhang's optimism. Some raised concerns about the partnership with Binance and its potential impact on Scroll's decentralization efforts.

然而，並非加密社群中的每個人都像張一樣樂觀。有些人對與幣安的合作關係及其對 Scroll 去中心化工作的潛在影響表示擔憂。

Jiajun, an Ether ( ETH ) advocate and X user, expressed disappointment, saying, "Binance is not the exchange that should have listed Scroll first. If the chain had enough activity and users, Binance would have listed it organically without needing a partnership. Now everyone will think Binance listed Scroll first because it paid them the most."

以太坊（ETH）倡議者、X用戶Jiajun對此表示失望，他表示：「幣安並不是應該先上線Scroll的交易所。如果這條鏈有足夠的活躍度和用戶，幣安就會有機地上線它，而不需要合作夥伴。

Other users on X suggested that Binance should not have been the first exchange to list Scroll. They argued that if the "chain had enough activity and users," Binance would have listed it organically, without the need for a partnership.

X 上的其他用戶建議幣安不應該是第一個上線 Scroll 的交易所。他們認為，如果“該鏈有足夠的活動和用戶”，幣安就會有機地列出它，而不需要合作夥伴。

"Binance listing should have been a natural consequence of chain activity, not the first exchange listing," said one user.

一位用戶表示：“幣安上市應該是連鎖活動的自然結果，而不是首次在交易所上市。”

In response to the criticism, Zhang defended the partnership, saying that Scroll is "decentralized at the protocol level," and the CEX integration is for user convenience.

針對批評，張為合作夥伴關係進行了辯護，稱 Scroll“在協議層面是去中心化的”，CEX 整合是為了用戶方便。

"We chose Binance as the first exchange to partner with because it will help onboard more users into the Scroll ecosystem," said the Scroll co-founder.

Scroll 聯合創始人表示：“我們選擇幣安作為第一個合作交易所，因為它將幫助更多用戶進入 Scroll 生態系統。”

Zhang also addressed concerns about token distribution, clarifying that launch pool allocation comes from the ecosystem and growth category, ensuring the community airdrop remains unaffected.

張也解決了對代幣分配的擔憂，澄清啟動池分配來自生態系統和成長類別，確保社區空投不受影響。