無止盡的爭論：中心化交易所及其加密資產上市費用

在加密世界中，關於中心化交易所Coinbase和Binance的加密資產上幣費用的爭論日益激烈。

TRON founder Justin Sun and Fantom founder Andre Cronje have made explosive claims regarding the crypto asset listing fees demanded by Coinbase and Binance, two of the largest centralized cryptocurrency exchanges in the world. These claims have sparked a heated debate within the crypto community.

TRON 創辦人 Justin Sun 和 Fantom 創辦人 Andre Cronje 對全球最大的兩家集中式加密貨幣交易所 Coinbase 和 Binance 所要求的加密資產上市費用提出了爆炸性的指控。這些說法引發了加密社群內的激烈爭論。

According to Justin Sun, Coinbase, the leading crypto exchange in the United States, demanded 500 million TRX (approximately $80 million at the time) from him to list TRON. This directly contradicts the statements made by Coinbase CEO Brian Armstrong, who has repeatedly claimed that listing assets on the exchange is free.

據孫宇晨透露，美國領先的加密貨幣交易所 Coinbase 向他索要 5 億 TRX（當時約 8,000 萬美元）才能上線 TRON。這與 Coinbase 執行長 Brian Armstrong 的聲明直接矛盾，後者多次聲稱在交易所上市資產是免費的。

In a series of tweets, Moonrock Capital CEO Simon Dedic also criticized the high fee demands of centralized exchanges. Dedic revealed that a high-capital project he worked with received a listing offer from Binance that would have required them to give the exchange 15% of their total token supply following a lengthy research and review process.

Moonrock Capital執行長Simon Dedic在一系列推文中也批評了中心化交易所的高額費用要求。 Dedic 透露，他合作的一個高資本項目收到了幣安的上市要約，要求他們在經過漫長的研究和審查過程後向交易所提供其總代幣供應量的 15%。

Dedic further stated that a listing fee in the range of $50 million to $100 million would be an unsustainable burden for most projects, especially considering the rapid decline in token prices that typically follows such listings.

Dedic 進一步表示，5,000 萬至 1 億美元的上市費用對於大多數項目來說將是一個不可持續的負擔，特別是考慮到此類上市後代幣價格通常會迅速下跌。

Coinbase CEO Armstrong responded to Dedic's criticism by highlighting once again that listing on Coinbase is free. However, Cronje quickly countered Armstrong's statement, alleging that Coinbase had, at various times, requested high amounts such as $30 million, $50 million, $60 million, and $300 million to list Fantom.

Coinbase 執行長阿姆斯壯回應了 Dedic 的批評，再次強調在 Coinbase 上上市是免費的。然而，Cronje 很快就反駁了阿姆斯壯的說法，聲稱 Coinbase 曾多次要求 3000 萬美元、5000 萬美元、6000 萬美元和 3 億美元等高額資金來上線 Fantom。

Cronje went on to state that he was prepared to share the relevant documents with the public to prove these fee demands. He argued that even if Coinbase did not explicitly refer to these payments as a "listing fee," the expenses were ultimately reflected under the guise of "earnings fee," which should be considered a de facto listing fee.

克羅涅接著表示，他準備與民眾分享相關文件，以證明這些費用要求。他認為，即使 Coinbase 沒有明確將這些付款稱為“上市費”，但這些費用最終還是以“收益費”的幌子反映出來，這應該被視為事實上的上市費。

Justin Sun also mentioned experiencing a similar situation, where Coinbase allegedly asked for 500 million TRX tokens to list TRON, along with an additional $250 million in Bitcoin collateral on Coinbase Custody to enhance performance.

賈斯汀·孫（Justin Sun）也提到經歷過類似的情況，據稱Coinbase 要求提供5 億個TRX 代幣來列出TRON，並在Coinbase Custody 上額外提供2.5 億美元的比特幣抵押品以提高性能。

In response to these discussions, Binance exchange co-founder Yi He clarified that Binance does not accept any tokens or money in exchange for favorable treatment in the listing process. He stated that Binance has a rigorous screening policy and that it is not possible to bypass this process.

針對這些討論，幣安交易所聯合創始人何一澄清，幣安在上市過程中不接受任何代幣或金錢來換取優惠待遇。他表示，幣安有嚴格的篩選政策，不可能繞過這項流程。

Yi He also addressed the issue of token distribution, explaining that Binance considers certain rates in the listing process, but not to the extent of demanding 20% or 15% as has been alleged. He added that there are specific rules for applications like airdrops in Binance's listing processes.

何一也談到了代幣分配問題，解釋說幣安在上市過程中考慮了一定的比例，但沒有達到所謂的20%或15%的程度。他補充說，幣安的上市流程中對於空投等申請有特定的規則。

These events demonstrate the substantial influence wielded by centralized exchanges within the crypto ecosystem and the significant financial pressures that projects can encounter to gain access to these platforms.

這些事件顯示了加密貨幣生態系統內中心化交易所所產生的巨大影響力，以及專案在存取這些平台時可能遇到的巨大財務壓力。