Willie Peters' Selection Headache: Sam Tomkins and Jon Wilkin Weigh In

Sam Tomkins and Jon Wilkin analyze Willie Peters' selection dilemma for the semi-finals, focusing on Joe Burgess, Oliver Gildart, and Jack Broadbent.

Willie Peters' Selection Headache: Sam Tomkins and Jon Wilkin Weigh In

Hull KR head coach Willie Peters faces a major selection dilemma as the semi-finals approach. With a near fully-fit squad, the choice between Joe Burgess, Oliver Gildart, and Jack Broadbent is causing quite the stir, with rugby league legends Sam Tomkins and Jon Wilkin offering their insights.

The Dilemma: Who Starts?

Following their League Leaders’ Shield victory, the Robins are gearing up for a crucial semi-final clash. The availability of Joe Burgess and the return of Oliver Gildart add to the complexity, especially with Jack Broadbent's impressive form this season.

Gildart, a three-time England international, was a standout performer before a knee injury sidelined him. Meanwhile, Broadbent has seized the opportunity, racking up 13 tries and 14 assists across multiple positions. This leaves Peters with a tough choice: experience or current form?

Tomkins and Wilkin's Verdicts

Former England captain Sam Tomkins acknowledged the difficulty of the decision: “It’s a difficult one. We’ve seen both be good and both be vulnerable at times. Oli has had a knee issue, so coming back, he’s not been in form. It’s a toss of a coin, I’m not sure.”

Jon Wilkin, however, was more decisive: “Jack Broadbent for me.”

The Stakes

With just 80 minutes separating the Robins from a potential return to Old Trafford, Peters' selection call could make or break their chances. The semi-final is set for Saturday, October 4, adding urgency to this decision.

My Two Cents

While experience is valuable, Broadbent's versatility and current form make him a compelling choice. His ability to perform in multiple positions offers flexibility, which could be crucial in a high-stakes match. That said, Gildart's experience in big games can not be discounted. Ultimately, it's Peters' call, and he will know which player best suits the game plan.

So, grab your popcorn and settle in because whatever happens, the semi-final is bound to be a nail-biter. Let’s see who Peters picks and if his choice leads the Robins to glory!