Liberty Seated Dollar, 1870, Harlan Berk: Unveiling a Numismatic Mystery

Explore the allure of the 1870-S Liberty Seated Dollar, focusing on the F.C.C. Boyd specimen acquired by Harlan J. Berk, Ltd. Uncover the coin's rich history.

Liberty Seated Dollar, 1870, Harlan Berk: Unveiling a Numismatic Mystery

The 1870-S Liberty Seated Dollar continues to captivate collectors. Harlan J. Berk, Ltd.'s acquisition of the F.C.C. Boyd specimen adds another layer to its storied past. This article dives into the history and intrigue surrounding this rare coin.

The Enigmatic 1870-S Coinage

The San Francisco Mint's output in 1870 presents a numismatic puzzle. Official records contradict contemporary accounts, particularly regarding the striking of half dimes, quarters, silver dollars, and $3 gold pieces. Legend says these coins were made for the cornerstone of the new Mint building.

Despite official denials, a few examples have emerged. The 1870-S Liberty Seated Half Dime is thought to be unique, and only a handful of 1870-S Liberty Seated Dollars exist. This scarcity and the conflicting records have fueled speculation for over a century.

The F.C.C. Boyd Specimen: A Piece of History

The 1870-S dollar acquired by Harlan J. Berk is particularly significant. This is the F.C.C. Boyd specimen. The Boyd specimen first surfaced in 1926. Originally, it bore the initials “FHI” on the obverse, but were later removed. Despite the tooling, the coin remains a crucial piece of numismatic history.

While other 1870-S dollars may be in better condition, the Boyd specimen holds historical importance as the first to be publicly offered. It has passed through notable collections and auction houses, most recently selling for $141,000 before being offered by Harlan J. Berk, Ltd. for $275,000. Another dealer is offering a PCGS XF40 for $1.325 million, highlighting the variance in value based on condition.

The Allure of the Unknown

Why were these coins produced, and for whom? The mystery surrounding the 1870-S coinage continues to fascinate. From H.O. Granberg's 1914 exhibition to Harlan J. Berk's recent acquisition, the 1870-S Liberty Seated Dollar maintains its allure. It’s a tangible link to a bygone era, shrouded in just enough mystery to keep collectors hooked.

So, if you ever stumble upon an 1870-S Liberty Seated Dollar, especially one with a story like the F.C.C. Boyd specimen, you might just have a piece of history—and a darn good conversation starter.