Solana社区的一部分批评了SIMD-228提案，理由是高集中化风险

该提案旨在通过从固定速率令牌排放到基于市场的模型将资产通货膨胀率降低80％。

A section of the Solana community has criticized the SIMD-228 proposal for its high centralization risk. The proposal seeks to reduce the asset inflation rate by 80% by moving from a fixed-rate token emission to a market-based model.

Solana社区的一部分批评了SIMD-228提案的高集中化风险。该提案旨在通过从固定速率令牌排放到基于市场的模型将资产通货膨胀率降低80％。

Over the past week, mixed views circulated on digital asset spaces. At the time of writing, proponents have secured the necessary quorum (71.85%) in favor.

在过去的一周中，混合视图在数字资产空间上散发。在写作时，支持者获得了必要的法定人数（71.85％）。

Validators Lambast Possible Risks

验证者lambast可能的风险

Crypto enthusiast Dave wrote on X that the move will favor larger validators over smaller players. He added that this will lead to high centralization and a scenario where the rich get richer.

加密爱好者戴夫（Dave）在X上写道，此举将偏爱较大的验证者而不是较小的球员。他补充说，这将导致高集中化和富人变得更富有的情况。

Solana validator SolBlaze.org noted that SIMD-0228 threatens Solana’s decentralization and the wider ecosystem. While it sounds good in theory, presently, the fixed 15% inflation decrease will be taken to extreme levels. According to the validator, rewards will plunge up to 80% with users looking for better yield. This reduced stake affects network security and disproportionately affects small validators.

Solana验证器Solblaze.org指出，SIMD-0228威胁了Solana的权力下放和更广泛的生态系统。虽然从理论上讲听起来不错，但目前，固定的15％通货膨胀率下降将降低到极端水平。根据验证者的说法，奖励最多将跌至80％，而用户寻求更好的收益。减少的股份会影响网络安全性，并不成比例地影响小验证器。

These network participants at 0% interest maintain servers and get block fees. Furthermore, Solana Foundation President Lily Liu described the proposal as half-baked, pointing to the benefits of a predictable capital market.

这些网络参与者的利息为0％，维持服务器并获得阻止费用。此外，索拉纳基金会主席莉莉·刘（Lily Liu）将该提案描述为半生，指出了可预测的资本市场的好处。

Liu added that infrastructure remains the foundation of most networks and needs a certain level of stability.

刘补充说，基础架构仍然是大多数网络的基础，并且需要一定程度的稳定性。

“What’s the greater risk and cost to our ecosystem: overpaying for security, or underinvesting in growth? On security: we were dogged for years as the centralized VC chain. We finally overcame that. But now we have 228 which is a VC proposal that centralizes the network! On growth: we’ve achieved impressive growth – and we need to continue to invest. Other ecosystems have noticed our ascent and are gearing up to compete,” Lui wrote.

“我们的生态系统的风险和成本更大：超额付费或投资不足的增长是多少？关于安全性：我们被钉在集中的VC连锁店中多年。我们终于克服了这一点。但是现在我们有了228，这是一个集中网络的风险投资提案！关于增长：我们已经实现了令人印象深刻的增长 - 我们需要继续投资。其他生态系统已经注意到了我们的上升，并正在准备竞争。” Lui写道。

Solana’s Co-founder Backs The Proposal

Solana的联合创始人支持该提案

Solana’s co-founder Anatoly Yakovenko backed the proposal, allaying the decentralization concerns. In an X post, he explained that the cost of inflation hitting $1-$2 billion annually will spark losses for small validators and wealth managers. Another argument for the proposal is the incentive for participation to secure the network while inflation drops.

Solana的联合创始人Anatoly Yakovenko支持了该提议，这表明了权力下放的问题。在X帖子中，他解释说，通货膨胀的成本每年达到1-2亿美元，将为小型验证者和财富管理人员带来损失。该提案的另一个论点是，在通货膨胀下降时，激励参与网络。

Per the release, higher inflation drives centralization. On the other hand, low inflation fuels Solana’s decentralized finance (DeFi) presence.

根据释放，较高的通货膨胀驱动了集中化。另一方面，低通胀为索拉纳（Solana）的分散融资（DEFI）的存在提供。

“Additionally, a high staking rate can be viewed as unhealthy for new DeFi protocols, since it means the implied hurdle rate is the inflation cost. Lowering the “risk-free” inflation rate creates stimulative conditions and allows new protocols to grow.”

“此外，对于新的DEFI协议，可以将高的放电率视为不健康，因为这意味着隐含的障碍率是通货膨胀成本。降低“无风险”通货膨胀率会产生刺激条件并允许新方案增长。”