幣安VS。 Coinbase 上市費用爭議

全球最大的兩家中心化交易所（CEX）幣安和 Coinbase 因代幣上市要求百萬富翁費用的指控而遭到強烈反對。

Binance and Coinbase, two of the largest centralized exchanges (CEXs) globally, faced backlash over allegations regarding millionaire fee requirements for token listing.

全球最大的兩家中心化交易所（CEX）幣安和 Coinbase 因有關代幣上市的百萬富翁費用要求的指控而面臨強烈反對。

On Thursday, Moonrock Capital’s CEO, Simon Dedic, shared his concerns regarding some CEXs’ listing requirements in an X post. Dedic stated that he recently spoke to a Tier 1 project that raised nearly nine figures. The project’s team detailed that they received a listing offer from Binance after “wasting over a year of due diligence” with the exchange.

週四，Moonrock Capital 執行長 Simon Dedic 在 X 貼文中分享了他對一些 CEX 上市要求的擔憂。 Dedic 表示，他最近與一個籌集了近九位數的一級項目進行了交談。該專案團隊詳細介紹說，他們在與交易所「浪費了一年多的盡職調查」後收到了幣安的上市要約。

However, the crypto exchange allegedly requested 15% of the token’s supply to secure the listing. Dedic expressed his concern about “paying $50-100M just for a CEX listing,” as it would be unaffordable for most projects, and the donated token supply is “the biggest reason for bleeding charts.”

然而，據稱該加密貨幣交易所要求提供 15% 的代幣供應量以確保上市。 Dedic 表達了他對「為 CEX 上市支付 50-1 億美元」的擔憂，因為這對大多數項目來說是難以承受的，而捐贈的代幣供應是「圖表出血的最大原因」。

Many community members discussed whether the listing fee requirement needed to change. One user argued that if a project wanted to be distributed in a CEX, they should “have to pay for it.”

許多社群成員討論了是否需要改變上市費用要求。一位用戶認為，如果一個項目想要在 CEX 中分發，他們應該「必須為此付費」。

Later on, Coinbase’s co-founder and CEO Brian Armstrong replied to Dedic’s X post. Armstrong stated that asset listings on Coinbase were free, which seemed to be a jab at Binance.

隨後，Coinbase 聯合創始人兼執行長 Brian Armstrong 回覆了 Dedic 的 X 貼文。阿姆斯壯表示，Coinbase 上的資產上市是免費的，這似乎是向幣安發動攻擊。

However, Sonic Labs’ founder, Andre Cronje, refuted Armstrong’s claim and revealed that Coinbase allegedly asked the company for a listing fee several times. Per the post, Coinbase requested up to $300 million from Sonic Labs, while Binance charged the project $0.

然而，Sonic Labs 創辦人 Andre Cronje 駁斥了阿姆斯壯的說法，並透露 Coinbase 據稱多次向該公司索要上市費。根據該帖子，Coinbase 向 Sonic Labs 請求最多 3 億美元，而幣安則向該項目收取 0 美元。

Moreover, Cronje stated that Cronje stated that Cronje’s experience with Binance might differ from other projects as the listing happened years ago and might have changed since then.

此外，Cronje 表示，Cronje 表示，Cronje 在幣安的經歷可能與其他項目不同，因為上市發生在幾年前，並且從那時起可能已經發生了變化。

On Monday, Binance co-founders Changpeng Zhao and Yi He addressed the issue and denied the allegations.

週一，幣安聯合創始人趙長鵬和何一談到了這個問題並否認了這些指控。

Zhao thanked Sun for his support and highlighted the importance of the validation from someone who runs two competing exchanges. However, he expressed his concern about the “quote attacks” within the industry.

趙感謝孫的支持，並強調了經營兩個競爭交易所的人驗證的重要性。不過，他對業界的「報價攻擊」表示擔憂。

Zhao urged his peers to reduce these attacks and asked teams to work on their projects to secure a listing instead of focusing on the exchanges. Moreover, he highlighted that “Bitcoin never paid any listing fees.” Sun agreed with CZ, stating, “Focusing on building projects and Bitcoin is what truly matters.”

趙敦促他的同行減少這些攻擊，並要求團隊致力於他們的專案以確保上市，而不是專注於交易所。此外，他強調“比特幣從未支付任何上市費用。” Sun 同意 CZ 的觀點，並表示：“專注於專案建設和比特幣是真正重要的。”

Yi He, co-founder and Chief Customer Service Officer at Binance, also addressed the issue and called the allegations FUD:

幣安聯合創始人兼首席客戶服務官何一也談到了這個問題，並稱這些指控“FUD”：

FUD will never go away, but it makes us stronger. Gossip is easy to get traffic, and business competition is always full of dark sides; When you understand the rules of how the world works, you will no longer be easily swayed by rumors, and you will have the ability to think independently.

FUD 永遠不會消失，但它讓我們變得更強大。八卦很容易獲得流量，商業競爭總是充滿陰暗面；當你了解了這個世界運作的規律，你就不會再輕易被謠言所左右，你就會有獨立思考的能力。

She explained that a project won’t get listed if it doesn’t pass the screening process, and the exchange doesn’t charge a “so-called 20%” fee. Yi He also remarked that the exchange’s listing rules are “transparent and clear,” including the airdrop rules for Binance’s Launchpool. Ultimately, she urged the community to do their research when controversy sparks.

她解釋說，如果專案沒有通過篩選，就不會上市，而且交易所不收取「所謂的20%」費用。何一還表示，該交易所的上市規則“透明且明確”，包括幣安Launchpool的空投規則。最終，她敦促社區在引發爭議時進行研究。