Boynton Beach Coin Collection Theft: A Cautionary Tale

A home health aide in Boynton Beach stole a rare coin collection and other valuables, highlighting the importance of vigilance and trust when hiring caregivers.

The theft of a rare coin collection in Boynton Beach is making headlines, reminding us that even in our own homes, valuables can be at risk. This story serves as a cautionary tale about trust and security.

The Boynton Beach Coin Heist: What Happened?

In March 2025, a 65-year-old Boynton Beach man hired Alden Jerome Johnson as a home health aide. Over the next few months, the man and his wife noticed that valuables were disappearing. Among the missing items was a historic coin collection, valued at $30,000. This collection included silver coins from the 1800s and early 1900s, stored in specialized collector books. The wife also reported missing gold jewelry and a Louis Vuitton handbag.

The Investigation and Arrest

The Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office launched an investigation and discovered that Johnson had been selling coins and jewelry at VI Pawn in Boca Raton. Detectives recovered pawn records and merchandise matching the stolen items. The pawn shop manager identified Johnson as the seller, and fingerprint analysis confirmed his thumbprint on the pawn documentation. Johnson was arrested on June 19 and faces multiple felony counts.

Lessons Learned

This case highlights several important points. First, it underscores the need for thorough background checks when hiring home health aides or any caregiver. Second, it emphasizes the importance of securing valuable items, even within your own home. A locked cabinet wasn't enough; the missing key provided easy access. It's also crucial to regularly inventory valuables to quickly identify any losses.

My Take: Trust, But Verify

It's sad to think that someone trusted to provide care would betray that trust. While most caregivers are honest and compassionate, this incident serves as a stark reminder to always verify. Don't just take someone's word for it; do your due diligence. Get references, check backgrounds, and most importantly, trust your gut. If something feels off, it probably is. Investing in a home security system or discreet cameras could also provide an extra layer of protection.

A Little Humor to End On

On a lighter note, at least the thief didn't try to pay for anything with the old coins. Imagine the look on the cashier's face! But seriously, let's hope this arrest brings some peace of mind to the victims and serves as a deterrent to others. Stay vigilant, folks, and keep those coin collections safe!