All Blacks' Loose Forward Conundrum: New Faces and Familiar Battles

Robertson's first All Blacks squad sparks debate over loose forward selection, balancing experience with fresh talent. Will Kirifi's defensive prowess be enough?

All Blacks' Loose Forward Conundrum: New Faces and Familiar Battles

Scott Robertson's inaugural All Blacks squad has landed, and the loose forward selection is causing a stir. It's a blend of fresh blood and seasoned veterans, leaving fans and pundits alike dissecting every name. The big question: Can these choices deliver the physicality and dynamism needed to dominate?

New Caps and Shifting Sands

The inclusion of Du'Plessis Kirifi and Christian Lio-Willie signals a changing of the guard. Kirifi's journey is particularly compelling. After a taste of the wider squad in 2020, he's battled his way back, becoming a stalwart in the NPC. His defensive work rate is touted as a major asset, a quality Robertson clearly values. Lio-Willie gets the start in Dunedin, adding immediate impact to the forward pack.

The Savea Factor and the Papali'i Paradox

Ardie Savea's versatility remains key. With Sam Cane's absence, Savea is now free to roam between openside and other loose forward positions, giving Robertson flexibility. Dalton Papali'i, however, finds himself in a tricky spot. Ironically, Cane's departure might've narrowed Papali'i's opportunities, as Savea's presence allows for different back-up options. The coaches also look for bigger bodies, Finau got named into the team since he's a crucial factor in his selection.

Size Matters: The Hunt for Physicality

There's a clear emphasis on size and physicality in this selection. Samipeni Finau's retention underscores this. Robertson is clearly seeking players who can bring that raw power to the forward pack. The All Blacks want to dominate the contact zone, and these selections reflect that intent.

Kirifi's Opportunity: Defense as a Differentiator

Du'Plessis Kirifi's selection is intriguing. In a world of high salaries, Kirifi stayed and proved his worth in New Zealand. Now, he gets his shot, and his defensive prowess will be under the microscope. Can he bring the necessary bite to complement the All Blacks' attacking flair?

The Bigger Picture: Attrition and Opportunity

Robertson's squad isn't just about the first test against France. It's about building depth and resilience. Injuries are inevitable, meaning opportunities will arise for those on the fringes. This initial selection is merely the opening chapter in a long and demanding season.

The Final Whistle: A Selection Full of Intrigue

So, there you have it. The All Blacks' loose forward selection is a fascinating mix of established stars and emerging talent. It's a puzzle that Robertson is piecing together, and the early signs suggest he's prioritizing physicality and defensive steel. Will it pay off? Only time will tell. But one thing's for sure: the battle for loose forward supremacy is on, and it promises to be a captivating contest.