What is Proposer-Builder Separation (PBS) and how will it change Ethereum?

Understanding Proposer-Builder Separation (PBS)

1. Proposer-Builder Separation, commonly known as PBS, is a critical architectural upgrade within the Ethereum network designed to address centralization risks associated with block production. After the Merge, Ethereum transitioned to a proof-of-stake consensus mechanism where validators are responsible for proposing and attesting to blocks. However, this led to the emergence of sophisticated entities known as builders who specialize in maximizing transaction inclusion profits through practices like MEV extraction.

2. Under traditional block production, validators would receive bundles of transactions from searchers or bots and include them directly into blocks they propose. This allowed validators with advanced infrastructure to gain an unfair advantage, potentially leading to centralization. PBS introduces a structural division: the role of constructing full blocks is separated from the role of proposing them.

3. In the PBS model, specialized off-chain builder entities create fully formed blocks and submit them to proposers—the randomly selected validators—through a competitive bidding process. The proposer then selects the highest-paying valid block without knowing its contents, reducing their ability to manipulate transaction ordering for personal gain.

4. This separation enhances decentralization by allowing smaller validators to participate fairly. Even if a validator lacks the computational resources to optimize transaction bundles, they can still earn rewards by selecting blocks from professional builders. It effectively democratizes access to MEV revenue while preserving network security.

5. PBS was initially implemented in a partial form via services like Flashbots’ MEV-Boost, which allows validators to outsource block building. Although not yet fully integrated at the protocol level, this interim solution has become widely adopted, with the majority of Ethereum blocks currently being produced using MEV-Boost relays.

The Impact of PBS on Ethereum’s Decentralization

1. One of the primary motivations behind PBS is to prevent the centralization of block production. Without separation, large staking pools could vertically integrate by running their own proprietary builders, gaining disproportionate influence over transaction inclusion and network performance.

2. By enabling an open market for block construction, PBS fosters competition among independent builders. This competitive environment drives innovation and efficiency while preventing any single entity from dominating the block-building process.

3. The introduction of PBS significantly reduces the barrier to entry for individual validators, ensuring that even small-scale participants can remain economically viable. Validators no longer need to invest heavily in complex infrastructure to extract MEV; instead, they rely on external bids, promoting a more distributed validator set.

4. Additionally, PBS mitigates censorship risks when paired with mechanisms like proposer boosting and distributed relay architectures. Multiple geographically dispersed relays ensure that no single point of failure or control exists in the block submission pipeline.

5. Over time, this architecture strengthens Ethereum’s resilience against coercion and regulatory pressure. Since proposers do not construct blocks themselves, they cannot be easily forced to exclude specific transactions, enhancing censorship resistance across the network.

How PBS Influences MEV and Network Security

1. Maximal Extractable Value (MEV) refers to the profit that can be extracted by reordering, inserting, or censoring transactions within a block. Prior to PBS, MEV posed a systemic risk, as it incentivized validators to prioritize personal gains over network fairness.

2. PBS does not eliminate MEV but rather internalizes it into a transparent marketplace. Builders compete to offer the highest bid for the right to build a block, and these payments flow back to validators through tips. This transforms MEV into a predictable revenue stream rather than an opaque advantage held by well-resourced actors.

3. By making MEV extraction visible and competitive, PBS reduces information asymmetry and prevents covert manipulation of the transaction mempool. It also encourages ethical MEV strategies, such as fair-share models and MEV smoothing across validator sets.

4. From a security standpoint, PBS helps protect against long-range attacks and bribery attempts. Because block contents are sealed before reaching the proposer, attackers cannot easily predict or interfere with the final block structure, increasing the cost of successful exploits.

5. Furthermore, the modular design introduced by PBS lays the foundation for future scalability solutions like proposer slot auctions and data availability sampling. These advancements depend on a clean separation between proposal and construction roles, making PBS a prerequisite for next-generation Ethereum upgrades.

Frequently Asked Questions

What problem does PBS solve in Ethereum’s current architecture?

PBS addresses the growing centralization risk caused by the complexity and profitability of block construction. As MEV opportunities expanded, only well-funded validators with advanced infrastructure could efficiently capture these profits. This threatened to concentrate power among a few dominant players. PBS levels the playing field by allowing all validators to benefit from professional block builders through a transparent auction system.

Is PBS already active on Ethereum?

PBS is currently operating in a proto-form through MEV-Boost, a middleware solution that enables validators to accept externally built blocks. While this provides many of the benefits of PBS, it remains an extraprotocol layer. Full protocol-level PBS is expected to be integrated with future upgrades like EIP-4844 and the Verge, providing native support and enhanced security guarantees.

Can PBS reduce negative impacts of MEV on users?

PBS itself does not directly reduce harmful MEV practices such as frontrunning or sandwich attacks. However, it creates a framework where MEV can be better monitored, regulated, and redistributed. Solutions like SUAVE aim to work alongside PBS to enforce ethical ordering rules and return value to users, leveraging the transparency that PBS enables.

Does PBS make Ethereum slower or less efficient?

No, PBS improves efficiency by enabling specialized entities to focus exclusively on optimizing block construction. These builders use advanced algorithms and real-time market data to pack transactions more effectively than general-purpose validators could. The result is higher throughput and better utilization of block space without compromising decentralization.