|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
暗号通貨のニュース記事
The Impossible Dream of Cryptocurrency: Unlimited Programmability, Complete Decentralization, and Guaranteed Regulatory Compliance
2025/01/13 23:02

The cryptocurrency market is experiencing a pivotal shift with the appointment of Paul Atkins as SEC Chair. While his preference for market-driven solutions over heavy-handed enforcement bodes well for crypto, the industry faces a fundamental choice that no regulatory flexibility can resolve.
The essence of Web3 lies in automating complex interactions, such as stock exchanges. To achieve this, users must be empowered to create and upload their own assets and programs. However, this permissionless access poses challenges for users who may encounter malicious programs or scams, the system that could experience congestion, and regulators who are tasked with preventing financial crimes.
The crux of the dilemma lies in a concept known as "undecidability" in computer science. Traditional finance regulators can easily impose rules like "no transactions with sanctioned entities" or "maintain capital adequacy ratios," which banks can implement through their existing control systems. But in a truly decentralized system, where anyone can deploy sophisticated smart contracts, it becomes mathematically impossible to verify in advance whether a new piece of code might violate these rules.
This reality is evident in JPMorgan's recent rebranding of Onyx to Kinexys. The platform now processes over $2 billion in daily transactions, with participation limited to participants who meet regulatory criteria before joining. Unlike typical cryptocurrency platforms where anyone can write and deploy automated trading programs (known as smart contracts), JPMorgan's system maintains compliance by restricting what participants can do.
This approach has attracted major institutional players like BlackRock and State Street, which collectively have more than $15 trillion in assets under management. However, many crypto enthusiasts view such restrictions as betraying the technology's promise. These compromises are not merely pragmatic choices – they are essential for any system that aims to guarantee regulatory compliance.
The Securities and Exchange Commission's mandate to protect investors while facilitating capital formation has grown increasingly complex in the digital age. Under Gary Gensler's leadership, the SEC took an enforcement-heavy approach to crypto markets, treating most digital assets as securities requiring strict oversight. While Atkins' anticipated principles-based approach might seem more accommodating, it cannot change the underlying mathematical constraints that make automated compliance impossible in permission-less, fully programmable systems.
The limitations of fully automated systems became painfully clear at MakerDAO, one of the largest decentralized lending platforms with over $10 billion in assets. During March 2024's market turbulence, when Bitcoin's price swung 15% in hours, MakerDAO's automated systems began triggering a cascade of forced liquidations that threatened to collapse the entire platform.
Despite years of refinement and over $50 million spent on system development, the protocol required emergency human intervention to prevent a $2 billion loss. Similar incidents at Compound and Aave, which together handle another $15 billion in assets, underscore that this wasn't an isolated case. This wasn't just a technical failure – it demonstrates the impossibility of programming systems to handle every potential scenario while maintaining regulatory compliance.
The industry now has three paths forward, each with distinct implications for investors:
The first option is to follow JPMorgan's lead and build permission-based systems that sacrifice some decentralization for clear regulatory compliance. This approach has already gained significant traction: six of the top ten global banks launched similar initiatives in 2024, collectively handling over $2 trillion in transactions. The surge in regulated crypto products, from ETFs to tokenized securities, further validates this path.
The second path is to limit blockchain systems to simple, predictable operations that can be automatically verified for compliance. This is the approach adopted by Ripple with its newly launched RUSD, designed to be compliant with the New York Department of Financial Services standards based on the limited purpose trust company framework. While this constrains innovation due to the restriction action space that users can make, it enables decentralization within carefully defined boundaries.
The third option is to continue pursuing unlimited programmability while accepting that such systems cannot provide strong regulatory guarantees. This path, chosen by platforms like Uniswap with its over $1 trillion in total trading volume in 2024, faces mounting challenges. Recent regulatory actions against similar platforms in Singapore, the U.K. and Japan suggest this approach's days may be numbered in developed markets.
For investors navigating this evolving landscape, the implications are clear. The current market enthusiasm, largely driven by regulated products like ETFs, indicates the industry is moving toward the first option. Projects that acknowledge and address these fundamental constraints, rather than fighting them, are likely to thrive. This explains why traditional financial institutions' blockchain initiatives, despite their limitations, are seeing dramatic growth – JPMorgan's platform reported a 127% increase in transaction volume this year.
The success stories in crypto's next chapter will likely be hybrid systems that balance innovation with practical constraints. Investment opportunities exist in both regulated platforms that provide clear compliance guarantees and innovative projects that thoughtfully limit their scope to achieve verifiable safety properties.
As this market matures, understanding these mathematical constraints becomes crucial for investors' risk assessment and portfolio allocation. The evidence is
免責事項:info@kdj.com
提供される情報は取引に関するアドバイスではありません。 kdj.com は、この記事で提供される情報に基づいて行われた投資に対して一切の責任を負いません。暗号通貨は変動性が高いため、十分な調査を行った上で慎重に投資することを強くお勧めします。
このウェブサイトで使用されているコンテンツが著作権を侵害していると思われる場合は、直ちに当社 (info@kdj.com) までご連絡ください。速やかに削除させていただきます。

































